For about a year and half, my wife and I decided that we had enough of the use of plastic bags, although we did put them in the recycling bin or use them for other purposes. We started getting re-usable bags because we thought it would be indeed a nice personal move for the environment and because you could also pack things better in those types of bags compared to single use plastic bags. We haven’t completely eliminated single use bags but it currently rests at about 10% of our total bag use.

When we do our groceries, we do notice that more and more, people use these types of bags as well. How could you not? The population is flooded with advertising of all sorts to use these types of bags. However selling these bags have become profitable and a whole new industry has emerged. There are very few stores nowadays that don’t have their own re-usable bag. Heck even car dealership hand them out just for visiting them.
Like any industry who wants their product to be automatically bought and to be recognizing, you flood the market. Then when the market is flooded you try to convince people to leave the old and stay permanently with the new. This is exactly what is happening with this re-usable bag market. Now that we are flooded with them, the next step is to make you stop using the older method of single use bags.
Last year, in a few areas in Quebec, some retailers have stopped completely to give plastic bags for their products’ invoking it was the right thing for the environment. Some decided that they would reimburse you a nickel per re-usable bag you used for your items.
Fast forward to now: On Earth Day: Loblaws/Maxi/Provigo are now charging the client (you) a nickel per single use plastic bag. In June, Ikea, who already charges a nickel per bag, will stop giving out single use bags completely. Archambault, a music/movie/book store in Quebec will start to charge a dime per bag on August 1st.
If the motives for this were purely honest towards the environment, in most cases, I would not really have any problems with this. However people thinking that it’s for motives such as ”the greater good” they are fooling themselves.
This practice is nothing more than a cut in costs and making the customer pay for an item that is supposed to be part of your customer service. Loblaws state that all profits would go to the WWF-World Wildlife Foundation. They basically tell you what they are doing. Not paying for their own bags AND getting a tax deduction for donating to a non profitable foundation. This is true for every single business that is going into this new ”trend”.
What I find appalling is that companies that don’t even offer single use bags anymore will tell you, at the cash, that you can buy their branded re-usable bags for 1.00$.
Here is the catch 22: If your re-usable bag rip (which two of ours did within 6 months) what do you do with them? A lot of them ARE NOT RECYCABLE. That is the big question and problem. As usual we are trying to eliminate one problem by creating another, all to the profit of big enterprises. This has become a multi-billion business and uses a lot more in resource than it ever did for single use plastic bags.
I’m not ditching re-usable bags at all. We use them frequently, but I will not start holding on to them under my arm while I do my Xmas shopping. I also think that we can all agree that single use plastic bags are not really used only once. Some use them as garbage bags, others simply to store little things in them and put those on coat hangers in the closet. We have all used them to put our wet towels and bathing suits in. I agree that many do end up at dump sites but that’s where recycling programs failed.
The hard truth is that this whole banning or charging client for bags thing was not looked at closer by the authorities. Using only the garbage bag use supposition for single use bags, people will now have to actually buy garbage bags which are bigger than what they really need. Hence again, more ressources are used to make them, since they are more demand and more plastic is off to the dump. Let’s face it; you need to balance the lesser of both evils here.
The real solution is the bio-degradable bag, mandatory for all stores. I’ve seen those in action and they work. I had an HMV bag (which are biodegradable) for a year stored under my “DVDs to watch” pile. When I took it to use it, half of it had disintegrated itself. How about that!? Apparently the maximum time it takes is 5 years to decompose.
So why not go in that direction, at least for the time being right now? Because corporations decided otherwise when they saw how profitable this whole re-usable bag business can be.
There is nothing heart worthy of the intentions of business to go green: it’s all about business. If one offers products that are less pollutant to the environment, I’m all for it. Where I draw the line is when you hold people hostage when you do. Believe me that this is exactly what the population is being held for.
Why is that every time I go to a store to buy product A, B or C, and that I honestly forget to bring a re-usable bag , I get a gloomy and evil look from some of the staff? Because I dared to ask for a bag because I was walking for a while. Hey, screw you! You don’t know me; you don’t know how much I do my part in recycling. I doubt they even do it themselves.
Again, don’t get me wrong. I love using re-usable bags. I try to bring them as much as I can with me. However, for those times that I do forget or I am elsewhere out of my city, I don’t want to have to worry about a business not offering a bag or charging me for it. In any case, I refuse to pay and leave all my stuff at the cash register unless it is urgent.
For now, I urge everyone to not buy at business’ that don’t offer this basic service. This whole banning on bags or charging for them is a money making scheme at its finest.
For the people who don’t think it’s a big deal. Go to Ikea and buy a whole bunch of things. Once you realized you forgot to bring your re-usable bags, which you usually don’t do, send me an email and let me know how it felt to have to spend money on yet another re-usable bag that you paid for piling up with your others that you have been gathering.
And that, my friends, is the truth!
Filed under: Environment, Shopping, Society | Tagged: bags, Environment, ikea, loblaws, maxi, plastic, re-usable bags, recycling, Shopping, Society | 1 Comment »